Nokomis Probate Attorney

Estates administered for Casey Key, mainland Nokomis, and out-of-state families.

When someone dies holding a Casey Key oceanfront home or a mainland Nokomis bungalow, the family is suddenly running a probate matter inside the 12th Judicial Circuit. Generic Florida handling misses the ancillary work and the venue mechanics. We close these estates cleanly.

Request a free consultation
FindLaw attorney directory badge
American Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys 10 Best 2016 client satisfaction award
Lawyers.com attorney directory badge
Martindale.com attorney directory badge
Million Dollar Advocates Forum award badge

Probate Built for How Nokomis and Casey Key Estates Actually Move Through Court

Many Nokomis probate matters are Casey Key second-home estates of out-of-state decedents. The primary estate is administered up north, but the Florida-situs oceanfront property triggers an ancillary administration under Chapter 734 in Sarasota County.

Generic Florida probate handling misses the specifics. Casey Key estates need Ch. 734 ancillary procedure, will-contest readiness, and trust-administration sequencing. Mainland Nokomis estates need clean summary administration paths.

Hurricane Milton’s October 2024 storm surge added another layer. Insurance-proceeds claims now sit inside active Casey Key probate files, waiting on the Personal Representative to collect them.

Procedural rules tightened too. The 10-day will deposit deadline still applies, and CS/HB 923 took effect January 1, 2025, with the 12th Circuit’s updated probate checklist.

Our role is moving these matters through cleanly. Allie R.B. Castellano leads our estate planning and probate practice and has argued at the Florida Appellate Court.

Proudly Serving Nokomis, Casey Key, and Surrounding Communities

Our clients come from across the area: Casey Key oceanfront families along Casey Key Road, mainland Nokomis homeowners, Sorrento Shores and Sorrento East retirees, families in Laurel, and households near the Albee Road bridge. We also serve Osprey and northern Venice.

Nokomis probate is filed at the Judge Lynn N. Silvertooth Judicial Center, 2002 Ringling Boulevard in Sarasota, not the South County Courthouse on South Tamiami Trail in Venice. Karen Rushing’s Clerk’s Office handles will deposit within 10 days of death and the Letters of Administration. Ancillary cases under Chapter 734 are routine here.

Casey Key shapes the practice. Out-of-state decedents holding multi-million-dollar oceanfront homes drive a steady stream of ancillary administrations and the occasional will contest over a beachfront residence. Post-Milton, several active probate files now sit on top of unresolved storm-surge insurance claims waiting to be collected by the Personal Representative.

We are rooted here. Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. has served Sarasota County for decades. Allie has argued at the Florida Appellate Court and received the William F. Blews Pro Bono Service Award.

Lost a loved one in Nokomis? Schedule a free, confidential consultation with Allie Castellano today.

Request a free consultation

Why Nokomis Probate Often Requires Specialized Handling Inside the Twelfth Circuit

Nokomis probate sits at an unusual intersection: Casey Key barrier-island wealth on one side, modest mainland estates on the other, and a Sarasota County procedural layer in between. Six situations come up over and over.

  • Ancillary probate of Casey Key second homes for out-of-state decedents
  • Will contests over high-value Casey Key beachfront homes and estates
  • Summary administration for modest mainland Nokomis estates under $75,000
  • Trust administration of family trusts holding Casey Key real estate
  • Hurricane Milton insurance-proceeds litigation inside active probate files
  • Personal Representative duties and creditor claim deadlines in the 12th Circuit

Each issue is solvable, but only when the firm actually knows both halves of the Nokomis Probate market and the 12th Circuit procedural rhythm. A Casey Key ancillary case moves differently than a mainland summary administration, and a contested will demands a different posture than a routine trust administration sequence.

What a Nokomis Personal Representative Must Do

These seven duties apply to every Florida estate, but the workload behind each varies sharply depending on whether the estate is Casey Key beachfront or mainland modest.

  • Deposit the original will within 10 days
  • File the petition for administration
  • Inventory and value all estate assets
  • Publish notice to creditors timely
  • Pay valid claims within statutory windows
  • File federal and Florida fiduciary returns
  • Distribute remaining assets to beneficiaries

Two duties matter more in Nokomis than in most Florida cities. Asset inventory on a Casey Key oceanfront home requires appraisal coordination and post-Milton flood and wind claim valuation. The 90-day creditor claim window under §733.702 is often the longest variable on mainland administrations.

How to Start Your Nokomis Probate Matter with Our Firm Today

The first step is a confidential consultation, either in our office or virtually. Bring the original will, the death certificate, deed copies for any Florida real estate, recent account statements, and a brief summary of the family. The initial conversation is at no charge for new clients.

After the consultation, we file the petition for administration with Karen Rushing’s Clerk’s Office and request Letters of Administration appointing the Personal Representative. For Casey Key ancillary cases, we coordinate with primary-estate counsel in the decedent’s home state. For mainland estates, we sort summary versus formal here.

From there we manage notice to creditors, asset gathering, fiduciary tax filings, any open insurance-proceeds collection, and beneficiary distributions. We see the matter through to Order of Discharge, including will-contest defense if the estate is challenged at any stage during administration in the 12th Circuit.

How We Handle Your Nokomis Probate Matter

Probate is rarely something a family expected to be running this week. The reader is grieving and time-pressured, and the procedural calendar started on the day of death. Our role is to take the filing load, the deadline calendar, and the creditor coordination off the family so the people closest to the decedent can focus on grieving and on each other.

From there we shape the matter to the estate. Nokomis probate cases rarely look the same. A Casey Key oceanfront home owned by a Connecticut decedent runs as a Chapter 734 ancillary case parallel to the primary estate up north. A Sorrento East retiree bungalow under $75,000 runs as a summary administration. A Casey Key family trust holding the beachfront avoids probate but still requires careful administration.

We coordinate with the Clerk’s Office for will deposit and Letters of Administration, appraisers for Casey Key asset valuation, insurance adjusters for unresolved Hurricane Milton storm-surge claims inside the estate, and the family’s accountant for federal and Florida fiduciary tax filings.

And we see the matter through to closure. Our work runs through final accounting, distribution, and Order of Discharge from the court.

Recent Nokomis Matters

  • Case results

    $1.6 Million

    Will Contest

  • Case results

    $1.175 Million

    Fiduciary Breach

  • Case results

    $300,000

    Trustee Fraud

  • Case results

    $260,000

    Trust Recovery

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case turns on its own facts

Probate in Nokomis and Casey Key, By the Numbers

The 12th Judicial Circuit covers Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto Counties and processes thousands of probate, guardianship, and trust matters every year. Every Nokomis probate filing moves through the Silvertooth Judicial Center in Sarasota, and a meaningful share involves Casey Key second-home decedents living in other states.

The wealth contrast drives complexity. Mainland Nokomis carries a median household income near $41,916 and roughly 28.5 percent of residents age 65 or older, which produces a steady volume of summary administrations on modest estates. Adjacent Casey Key carries multi-million-dollar oceanfront homes, so ancillary administrations and will contests cluster disproportionately on the barrier island.

The post-Milton period added a layer of barrier-island claim work. Casey Key Personal Representatives now navigate storm-surge insurance proceeds, FEMA-related considerations, and rebuild timing inside active probate and trust administration files.

Sources: Florida Statutes §28.241; U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2024; 12th Judicial Circuit Probate Division.

Statistics 2022

Median Household Income

$41,916

Residents Age 65+

28.5%

Counties in Circuit

3

What Our Nokomis Clients Say

My highest recommendation and gratitude to the firm of Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. Their generous reliability and core knowledge is truly valuable. Complex legal issues are strategically and efficiently handled. Communication was always prompt, and always my needs were a priority. Competency in cost-benefit analysis resulted in my receiving appropriate compensation. During the procedure, I experienced the highest ethical standards. This firm is truly superior in all regards.

The whole firm fought like hell for me and my family in Court. I highly recommend them.

Our experience with Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. is very positive. They handled all the unexpected annoyances – the E-mails, letters and phone calls that resulted from a relatively minor accident. We are satisfied with our result.

“Drake, Amiee and Nancy were very instrumental in helping me get through a very difficult time in my life. They were very warm and responsive to all my needs at any time. I would highly recommend this team of professionals in any legal matters.

I would highly recommend Drake Buckman to represent myself and any of my loved ones. From the initial contact, Drake always had my best interest, health and welfare as a priority. His friendly, personable manner gave me comfort and confidence from the start of my legal pursuit. Drake Buckman was thorough the entire duration of my case achieving success on my behalf

I found Amiee Buckman to be very attentive, thorough, professional, and very prompt in responding to my needs. I was impressed with not only her professionalism and expertise, but also with her sincerity and honesty. I would highly recommend Amiee Buckman and the firm of Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. to anyone that needed services in the area of law.

Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. has provided outstanding legal representation for us in the area of Estate Planning and Elder Care. Helped us through a difficult situation with a loved one that resulted in a successful outcome.

I am a client of the Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. law firm which I use for all my corporate and personal matters. Amiee has a personal hands on approach with attention to details and emphasis on communication. It is with great confidence I recommend her and the entire staff at this firm.

Drake is a conscientious person and a knowledgeable attorney. He’s a great counselor to have working for you. His costs are reasonable; and he will tell you the truth whether that’s what you want to hear or not. He’s experienced in writing Wills and setting up trusts and estates. I highly recommend him.

Mr. Buckman is a highly-skilled Professional who expedited my case efficiently and effectively. He was ethical, knowledgeable, patient and thorough from start to finish. I could not have asked for anything more!

Nokomis and Casey Key families come to us when they need a probate matter handled cleanly, whether the estate is an oceanfront home or a modest mainland bungalow.

Talk With Us

  • Formal & Summary Administration

  • Ancillary Probate & Disposition Without Administration

  • Will Contests & PR Duties

  • Trust Administration

Meet Allie R.B. Castellano

Allie leads estate planning and probate at Buckman, Buckman & Castellano, P.A. She argued at the Florida Appellate Court, shaping Florida case law on the right to direct one’s estate plan, and received the William F. Blews Pro Bono Service Award.

Her approach is plainspoken. Probate is overwhelming, and most families arrive needing clarity more than legal performance. Allie walks the family through what gets filed, when it gets filed, and what happens at each stage of the 12th Circuit calendar. She closes matters cleanly, from the petition for administration through the Order of Discharge.

Allie R.B. Castellano, Sarasota estate planning attorney, outside a Sarasota courthouse building

Allie R.B. Castellano

Partner

The probate matters that close cleanly are the ones where the family knows exactly what is happening next.

Read more

Our Practice Areas

Revocable living trust icon

Revocable Living Trust

Durable power of attorney icon

Durable Power of Attorney

Power of attorney icon

Power of Attorney

Business law icon

Business Lawyer

Simple will icon

Simple Will

Property deeds and transfers icon

Property Deeds and Transfers

Succession planning icon

Succession Planning

Estate planning icon

Estate Planning

Probate icon

Probate

Beneficiary rights icon

Beneficiary Rights

Nokomis Probate Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to Protect Your Family’s Future?

Request a free consultation
Is Nokomis probate filed in Sarasota or at the Venice courthouse?

Nokomis probate is filed at the Judge Lynn N. Silvertooth Judicial Center, 2002 Ringling Boulevard, Sarasota. The South County Courthouse on South Tamiami Trail in Venice handles certain civil and criminal matters for southern Sarasota County but not probate. The original will must be deposited with Karen Rushing’s Clerk’s Office within 10 days of learning of the death.

Who handles a Casey Key estate if the decedent lived in Connecticut?

The Casey Key home triggers Florida ancillary administration under Chapter 734 even when the primary estate is administered in Connecticut. A Florida Personal Representative is appointed in the 12th Circuit to handle the Florida-situs real property and any related claims. We coordinate with the Connecticut probate counsel running the primary estate and close both tracks in parallel.

How long does probate take for a multimillion-dollar Casey Key home?

Formal administration on a Casey Key home typically runs eight to fifteen months. The 90-day creditor claim window under §733.702 is the early floor, and Casey Key asset valuation, federal estate-tax filings, will-contest exposure, or unresolved Hurricane Milton insurance claims can extend the timeline. Cases without complications can close in roughly nine months once distribution is complete.

Can a beneficiary live in a Casey Key house during probate?

Often yes, but only with the Personal Representative’s consent and on terms that protect the estate. The PR retains authority over the home until distribution, and any occupancy needs to address insurance coverage, maintenance, and exclusion of other beneficiaries. We draft simple occupancy agreements that protect the estate and keep the Casey Key residence covered during the administration.

What happens to a flood-insurance claim if the homeowner dies before payout?

The pending claim becomes an asset of the estate. The Personal Representative steps in to collect on the policy after Letters of Administration are issued, signs claim documents on behalf of the estate, and directs the proceeds according to the will or Florida intestate rules. We have handled several open Hurricane Milton claims sitting inside active Casey Key probate files this way.